Quantcast
Channel: The Escapist Forums : Hot Threads
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 27009

Circumcision - Perhaps a good thing afterall?

$
0
0

Screw it, we're having this discussion again, it's been almost six months since last time and I've never gotten to truly participate in it.
Anyway, here it goes: After reading through the Wikipedia-article, it seems that most evidence is stacked towards male-circumcision preventing diseases from spreading, reducing cancer, or in a similar fashion being beneficial.
The counter-argument usually runs that it violates the mans autonomy, that he should be able to chose himself when he comes of age, and that there is a slight chance to loss of tactile-experience around the gland of the penis, possible causing less than optimal future sexual encounters.
However, I can't help but to see an analogy with viral-inoculation and the like. We inoculate babies all the time, and these too come with a risk and reward. There is a slight chance of complication, but the reward in general is perceived to out-weigh the risk.
Still, others may argue that we are right in ignoring the autonomy of others when it comes to inoculations because if we did not, a disease might spread from the non-inoculated, which put others at risk, and not just yourself. You are therefor not the only one affected by your choice.
I, though, can see a similar response when it comes to circumcision, since there have been evidence to suggest that those circumcised have a lower odds of spreading HIV to others (which might not be so important in the West, but very much so in Africa).

Right now, I am unsure of my position.


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 27009