I only ask because I feel like I might be in that sort of spot with Dark Souls right now. My problem is that I keep getting overly eager to try a different play-style, or join a different covenant, so I start a new file, and I never end up moving very far ahead in any of them because I keep bouncing around from character to character. I have one character that I've gotten pretty far with (up to Crystal Cave), but I've built him somewhat poorly, and I feel like I've kind of hit a wall with him.
It feels odd; I know I'm going to play the game for a while to come, yet I don't really see myself finishing it any time soon. I think it's because Dark Souls really feels like it's more about the journey than the destination, so to speak. My to finish games that I start isn't really kicking in.
So, fellow Escapists, are you in a similar scenario with any games you really like?